GnuCash and running a business?
Linas Vepstas
linas@linas.org
Tue, 22 May 2001 14:04:49 -0500
On Tue, May 22, 2001 at 11:03:09AM +0000, Gerd Arlitt was heard to remark:
> Paul Lussier wrote:
>
> >
> > I guess the things that I'd be interested in seeing in
> > business-related software would be things like:
> >
> > - payroll
> > - project tracking
> > - billing (time/services)
> > - personell/materiel management
> > etc.
> >
> I think you are plainly wrong here if you compare GnuCash with Applications
> like SAP or Peoplesoft in general. You'd better read some application
Right. SAP is a high end, and does very different things. But a more appropriate
comparison might be with peachtree, which comes shrink-wrapped, on a cdrom,
and support the above to a sifficeint degree to be usable in a small office.
What changes is when you have more than a handful of people using the system.
You can't go on with a simple pc-based app any more ...
The question was 'can gnucash, the pc-based app, be enhanced to support
peachtree/quickbooks style features'? and the answer is yes.
But if the question is 'can it be morphed into some mainframe-mangling
enterprise-class system', then no. Maybe absorbed by, merged into, but
not grown into.
> Overall consistency, (easy) adaptability to individual
> business needs are the problems..
> Once you get into the areas of material managment interleaved with supply
> logistics
> and prodution control and that in differing business types, it can become
> quite complex. And don't forget that organisational processes and software
> must go well together.
That's what gnue is meant to solve ...
> There is a lot more to say to this ... and I have my own views about the
> fututre in these areas, application and softwarewise. I am not convinced
> that conceptually redoing again and again what has been done 30 years ago
> already with punched cards is the way to go.
??
> I believe in new approaches and
> architectures which allow for better management of complexity of company
> processes as well as reducing the software complexity going with it.
Such as ??
> This may be all too much off topic .... maybe it can be discussed somewhere
> else but I woulden't know where ....
Nah, this is a great place, although the gnue place may be good too. Maybe
we should set up some sort of 'linux-financial' list? I don't beleive the
community has a general list of this kind.
--
Linas Vepstas -- linas@gnumatic.com -- http://www.gnumatic.com/