gnucash-hbci: Online transaction fails

[Christian Stimming]

Dear Joerg,

Joerg Sommer schrieb:
> if I issue an online transaction the hbci log shows:
> Ausgeführt.; Code 20, replyTo 4
> Nicht erwartet.; Code 9120, replyTo 3, additional 1,3

How often do you get this? Every day and every time you used 
gnucash-hbci so far? Or only on a specific day (which could point to a 
particular problem of the bank) or only with a specific transaction 
(which would point to a problem in openhbci)? Which bank is this? Which 
HBCI version are you using (look in the HBCI setup wizard, and on the 
page where the accounts are shown click on the button "HBCI version")?

> but gnucash-hbci opens the transcation window at the end as if all goes
> right. Code 9120 is a failure, 

Code 9120 is indeed a failure, but not necessarily a failure of the 
online transfer order. The transfer order might be the part of the HBCI 
message that got the "Ausgeführt, Code 20" (Completed) feedback, so it 
*could* be the case that everything went right as intended.

Also, the gnucash-hbci system in Version 1.8.3 now specifically checks 
for the result of the transfer *order* (as opposed to the complete HBCI 
message including setup and connection closing), and I think in version 
1.8.3 I really made sure you only get the "as if all goes right" 
behaviour if indeed the transfer order got a positive feedback so that 
it was accepted.

> but it seems gnucash-hbci doen't recognize
> it. I found a document with (maybe) all return code with hbci. Hope it
> could help you.
> http://www.hbci.de/download/HBCI220D/HBCI_LadenGeldKarte_Geschaeftsvorfall_v2.2.pdf 

Well of course the return codes are described in the HBCI 
specifications, and of course we have local copies of all the different 
HBCI specs. Again, your "code 9120" message might very well belong to 
the connection closing part of the HBCI message, so the transfer order 
itself went ok.

> gnucash: Debian 1.8.3-1
> gnucash-hbci: Debian 1.8.2-6

Wait, how is this supposed to work? A gnucash 1.8.3 but with 1.8.2 hbci 
module?!? Can you, by any chance, give me a list of files that are 
included in the gnucash-hbci package? And what was the build date for 
that package?

Christian