[GNC] Transaction line debit/credit in split view

NoobAlice NoobAlice at airmail.cc
Sun Jul 23 17:39:45 EDT 2023


On 2023-07-23 02:54 PM, john wrote:
> https://bugs.gnucash.org/show_bug.cgi?id=799041 coomplains that the 
> transaction line in split view shows the amount for the anchor split 
> in the register account in the Tot Debit or Tot Credit columns instead 
> of the value in the transaction currency as is shown in the 
> single-line view. He proposes that the transaction line in split view 
> should also show the value in the transaction currency, that is shares 
> * price. Does anyone have an opinion about this? 


I sometimes found Steven Bruniges' writing a little difficult to follow, 
so pardon if I've missed something.  I disagree with him; the 
transaction line in the split view shouldn't show the value in the 
transaction currency because the share price isn't being shown.  (Why 
doesn't he have the "Price" column header?)

My preferences would be, referencing the first two screenshots from the 
original bug:

Screenshot https://bugs.gnucash.org/attachment.cgi?id=374842
* Leave all numbers as-is

Screenshot https://bugs.gnucash.org/attachment.cgi?id=374843
* In the "Tot Sell" column remove the top black 3 and leave that cell blank.

In BOTH screenshots
* change heading "Balance" to "Shares Balance" to indicate it is not the 
cash value total but the shares total
* no need for "Tot" in any of the three column headings that use it.  
They are not really totals, which just makes this a little odd.


Surprisingly, this does not appear to be an issue in my single 
other-currency balance sheet account (except for the "Tot" parts of 
column heads), probably because conversion rates are not displayed in 
the register.




More information about the gnucash-user mailing list