Another Reports Bug

Colin Scott gnucash at double-bars.net
Mon Mar 21 17:24:00 EDT 2011


Bug reported 27/02/2011, but still showing as "uncomfirmed":

Bug 643406 - Income report permits selection of asset accounts but does not print them.

SUMMARY:

In 2.4.2, the Income Report permits the selection of Asset Accounts, but does not print an Assets section.

COMMENTARY:

1.  In 2.3.9, the Income Report would, if Asset accounts were selected, print out an Assets section in the report.  Customised Reports created based upon this behaviour now do not work.

2. Whether or not it is formally correct for the Income report to contain an assets section is, perhaps, open to debate, but it does not seem to be appropriate to attempt unilaterally to enforce "correct" procedure, especially as ideas of what is correct may vary wildly from country to country).

3. In any case, it is clearly incorrect behaviour to permit selection of accounts that are not actually included on the report:  either they should be included, or it should not be possible to select them. 

Colin


More information about the gnucash-user mailing list