HBCI

[Martin Preuß]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hi,

On Sonntag, 1. Dezember 2002 12:27, Eildert Groeneveld wrote:
[...]
> > When sending a transfer request to your credit institute you get a
> > message saying that your bank acknowledges the reception of your request
> > (normally something like "Auftrag entgegengenommen").
>
> Where do you get this notification? The transfers I dod looked totally
> normal to me. However, I have to admit that I did not explicitly look for
> something like "Auftrag entgegengenommen"; matter of fact, I do not
> remember ever having seen anything of this sort. Would that come up in one
> of those little windows?
These are questions only Christian Stimming can answer, since he developed the 
Gnucash-OpenHBCI interface.
I'm quite involved in OpenHBCI itself, but have absolutely no knowledge of the 
Gnucash part (I would have to dig into the whole GnuCash code to at least 
have a foggy view on what's going on inside ;-)

[...]
> Is there no way that openhbci is more explicit on the result from the
> transfer to the bank? If there is no aggreed (protocol) status (like 1 -
> transfer accepted) we should at least have a status box which tells you
> what the bank reported back: like "Auftrag entgegengenommen" (which would
> be fine) or " " then we would know there was something fishy.
>
> taking note of a HBCI transfer and trying to find it a few days later in
> the transactions list; this is simply not practical.
I totally agree, in fact, I think there should be a kind of feedback for all 
HBCI jobs you issue. Isn't there any type of status window ?
If not then it is simply a GUI matter (which I would like to pass to 
Christian), since OpenHBCI itself *does* maintain a detailed status for each 
job.

regards
Martin

- -- 

LibChipCard - http://www.libchipcard.de
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.7 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQE96g5yQg7xxPu3MA4RAqhQAJ0Sa0aJjt1ipgCDOQduGHwDaSUojgCeJvIw
QUK1Prf210g+qvuobow0jKc=
=jqjq
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----